Due to COVID-19 Molly Pitcher will be operating on a limited schedule and menu. Please check our Facebook page for the latest updates.


Our Menu


Small plates, perfect for sharing



Corn tortillas topped w/ pulled pork, shredded cheddar, jalapenos, & Redcoat ESB BBQ sauce.  Served w/ sides of salsa & sour cream.

Pretzel Bites


Soft pretzel bites served w/ Redcoat ESB beer cheese sauce.

Fried Wings


6 per order.

Your choice of Redcoat ESB BBQ sauce or Garlic Hot Sauce.  Served w/ housemade bleu-cheese dressing.

Grilled Chicken Wings


Dry-rubbed, hop-spiced chicken wings grilled, and served with w/ celery and warm sweet-onion and bleu-cheese sauce.
6 per order




French fries topped w/ seared stout-braised beef, local mozzarella cheese curds, and roasted-vegetable gravy.

Molly Tots


Fried potato fritters served with charred-onion mayonnaise and smoked-chili ketchup.


Burgers, and so much more

Crab Cake


Crab claw cake, breaded and seared, topped w/ roasted tomatoes, pickled red onions, and creamy herb dressing, on a brioche roll.

Goat Cheese and Jalapeno Burger


6oz sirloin burger topped w/ a goat cheese and pickled jalapeno sauce and horseradish potato strings, on a brioche roll.

Chickpea Cake


Spiced chickpea cakes, seared and topped w/ vegan “cheesy” sauteed onions and peppers, served on pita.

Melissa’s Famous Tuna Salad

A Carlisle staple returns!  Tuna Salad, with spring mix, tomatoes,  and ranch seasoned almonds, served on a brioche roll.

Bleu ‘Shroom Burger


6oz hop-spiced sirloin, topped w/ grilled mushrooms, and a sweet-onion and bleu-cheese sauce, on a brioche roll.

Bacon Burger


6oz sirloin burger topped w/ MPBC IPA-braised bacon, roasted garlic spread, smoked-chili ketchup and fontina cheese, on a brioche roll.

Braised Bacon Sandwich


Smoky slab bacon braised in garlic and MPBC IPA, sliced and grilled w/ barley malt and honey glaze, and topped w/ spicy jalapeño slaw, on a brioche roll.

Fried Chicken Sandwich


Buttermilk-soaked chicken thigh, breaded and fried, topped w/ roasted tomatoes, pickles, and charred-onion mayonnaise, on a brioche roll.

From The Kettle

House made soups

From The Field

Fresh, filling salad

Greek Chopped Salad


Shredded iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, pickled onions, shredded carrot, & Kalamata olives, topped w/ marinated feta & tossed in Greek dressing.

IPA Braised Bacon Salad


Thick-cut bacon, braised in MPBC IPA, then grilled and served atop spring-mix greens with pears, hop-spiced walnuts, and a bleu cheese-honey mustard dressing.

House Salad


Spring mix, grape tomatoes, spent grain croutons, cucumbers, choice of dressing.

For just $2 you can add Melissa’s Famous Tuna Salad or IPA Braised Bacon

(basil vinaigrette / vegan ranch / creamy herb / honey mustard bleu cheese)

Full and 1/2 size available

Sweet Treats


Sign Up For Molly News!

Get exclusive deals, a lunch punch card, coupons & more!